The Kitchen Table Gunsmith
  
   
Main menu  
 

 
 

 

Improving Two Pietta Remington 1858 New Army Revolvers – Part 2
by Roy Seifert

Click here to purchase a zip file with this and all Kitchen Table Gunsmith Articles.

 

Disclaimer:  This article is for entertainment only and is not to be used in lieu of a qualified gunsmith.  Please defer all firearms work to a qualified gunsmith.  Any loads mentioned in this article are my loads for my guns and have been carefully worked up using established guidelines and special tools.  The author assumes no responsibility or liability for use of these loads, or use or misuse of this article.  Please note that I am not a professional gunsmith, just a shooting enthusiast and hobbyist, as well as a tinkerer.  This article explains work that I performed to my guns without the assistance of a qualified gunsmith.  Some procedures described in this article require special tools and cannot/should not be performed without them.

Warning:  Disassembling and tinkering with your firearm may void the warranty.  I claim no responsibility for use or misuse of this article.  Again, this article is for entertainment purposes only!

Tools and firearms are the trademark/service mark or registered trademark of their respective manufacturers.   Click on any blue text to go to a product/seller web site.

Introduction
It’s been over six years since I first worked on my two Remington 1858 New Model Army Sheriff’s Model revolvers by Pietta (refer to my article Improving Two Pietta Remington 1858 New Army Revolvers).  In this article I will continue improving these revolvers based on videos I found on YouTube.  Here is my improvement plan:

·         Modify the cylinder base pin for reliability

·         Replace the spot-welded front sight with a dovetail front sight

·         Replace the spot-welded/epoxied loading lever latch with a dovetail latch

Modifying the Cylinder Base Pin for Reliability

Modified Remington 1858 New Model Army Cylinder Base Pin 

I recently saw a YouTube video by Everything Black Powder titled “The Ultimate Remington Upgrade” where Jake modified the cylinder base pin to eliminate fouling.  The photo above shows the modified cylinder base pin from Jake (a different Jake) Pearce’s revolver taken from Everything Black Powder’s video.  With this modified base pin, he fired 12 full cylinders (72 shots) with no lube and had no binding of the cylinder or action.  The only reason he stopped was because he ran out of lead round balls.  He used a Dremel tool and files to modify his base pin, but I have a lathe and CNC mill which should make the modifications easier.

If you notice in the above photo, the end of the base pin close to the barrel has been cut with angled grooves to cut and funnel fouling away from the frame and inside the center of the cylinder.  The center of the base pin has been narrowed so fouling does not bind the cylinder.

 Modified Cylinder Pin Measurements

The section with the grooves measures 0.175-inches wide, and the narrowed diameter part measures 1.000 x 0.188-inches.  I calculated this by using the Figure 1 photo, importing it into CorelDraw V12 and resizing it so the diameter of the base pin in the photo measured 0.272-inches, then measured the other parts in the photo.

 Turning the Base Pin

I purchased two spare cylinder base pins in case I made a mistake.  Based on the video and this article there may be a run on spare base pins!  I chucked a base pin in my lathe close to the fat end and used a small center drill to make an indentation in the end for a live center.  I pulled the base pin out and chucked it on the round end.  I used a live center in the indentation to prevent the pin from wobbling while turning. 

Turned Cylinder Base Pin

I turned down the base pin to the measurements above.  I used a 60o tool so the edges would be tapered.  I used the same tool to cut the groove on the opposite side of the cutting face to a depth of 0.040-inches.  You can still see the grooves I originally cut back in 2020.

 Cutting Face Measurements

I wanted to use the rotary Z-axis and my CNC mill to cut the cutting face on my modified base pin.  But first I had to do some calculations to figure out how much to rotate the Z-axis for each cut.

Z-axis Setting

Degrees

1.    Diameter

0.272”

 

 

2.    Circumference

0.855”

2.73

68.4 o

3.    Cutting face tooth width

0.070”

4.97

124.2 o

4.    Milling bit width

0.063”

7.20

180.0 o

5.    Rotation distance

0.133”

9.43

235.8 o

6.    % of circumference

0.155

11.67

291.6 o

7.    Degrees

55.82o

 

 

8.    Z-axis

2.23

 Rotary Z-Axis Settings

The above table shows my calculations.  Here is the math: 

1.    The diameter of the base pin is 0.272”.

2.    The circumference is 0.855”. (π * diameter, 3.141 * 0.272)

3.    The cutting face tooth width is 0.070” (see Figure 5 above).

4.    The milling bit width is 1/16, 0.0625” (see Figure 5 above).

5.    The pin has to be rotated 0.133-inches between cuts (tooth width 0.070 plus milling bit width 0.0625 = 0.133).

6.    0.133 is 15.5% of the circumference.  (0.133/0.855 = 0.155 = 15.5%)

7.    The pin has to be rotated 55.82-degrees between each cut. (360o * 0.155 = 55.82o)

8.    For every degree of movement, I need to enter a G-code command of A0.04.  To rotate 55.82-degrees I need a G-code of A2.23.

The rotary Z-axis works by position, not by degrees.  I built Table 1 by starting with a G-code of A7.2 to turn the base pin by 180o then subtracted 2.23 twice and added 2.23 twice.  If I start with the flat part of the base pin up so I can level it in my chuck, my first G-code command is G00A2.73.  This rotates the pin to position 68.4-degrees, then I make the 10-degree diagonal cut.  Next, I move the Z-axis to 124.2-degrees (G00A4.97) and make another 10-degree diagonal cut, and so on. 

 Milling Face Cuts

I chucked the base pin in the rotary Z-axis of my Max NC 10 CL CNC mill with the flat side up and supported the end with a dead center.  I used a 1/16 square-end bit to mill 10-degree diagonal grooves in the narrow section similar to the photo in the video.  I milled 0.0025” at a time so I wouldn’t break the small bit.  I milled to a depth of 0.042” which matched the depth of the milled center section. 

 Completed Base Pin Before Cold-Bluing

After all the milling was complete I applied Brownell’s Oxpho-Blue to the exposed metal.  Now the base pin can be reinstalled in the revolver.

Replacing the Spot-Welded/Epoxied Loading Lever Latch

 Uberti Loading Lever Latch

The loading lever latch was spot-welded in place.  I had removed the latch back in 2020 to turn grooves in the base pin, then used JB Weld to reinstall the latch.  The latch came free of the epoxy with just a light tap of a mallet.  To ease removal of the base pin, I wanted to replace the latch with a dovetail version.  Uberti makes their loading lever latch with a dovetail.  I purchased two Uberti loading lever latches from Gunpartscorp.com but these can be found cheaper elsewhere. 

The latch's dovetail is 0.347” wide at the bottom, the base is 0.060” thick.  The angle is 74 degrees, and the cutter used is 1/4 inch x 74 degrees, available from Brownells, part # 080-621-250.  I found a 74-degree carbide dovetail cutter on eBay for a lot cheaper.

 Mini Vise

I purchased a mini vise from Amazon to hold the barrel of the revolvers.  This vise came with pads for the jaws so I don’t mar the finish on the barrel.

I chucked the revolver upside-down in the milling vise for my CNC mill and leveled it.  I centered the mill over the mounting hole left from the latch. 

 Latch Milling Tool Paths

I took some measurements to tell me how to set the tool paths for the dovetail cutter.  The black lines in the above diagram represent the final dimensions of the dovetail cut.  The edges of the cut are 0.346” apart; 0.001” less than the actual width for a tight fit.  The green lines represent the tool paths.  The center green line is the tool path for initial cut to mill out the center of the dovetail cut.  The other green lines are the tool path for the edges of the dovetail cut. 

 Milling Loading Latch Dovetail

First, I milled the center of the dovetail cut using the dovetail cutter.  I cut 0.005” each pass until I cut to a depth of 0.060”.  After I milled the center of the dovetail cut, I kept the cutter at the 0.060” depth and milled the edges.  Although the cutter is carbide, I didn’t want to overload it so I took small cuts.  If you follow the arrows in the above diagram, you can see the toolpath.

Replacing the Spot-Welded Front Sight

 Uberti Front Sight

The front sight on these revolvers was also spot-welded in the barrel preventing them from being adjustable.  The Uberti model front sights are dovetailed in the barrel making them adjustable for windage.  I purchased two Uberti front sights also from Gunpartscorp.com.  A tap with a steel punch broke the sight free from the spot weld.

 Front Sight Center Milling Tool Path

The sight's dovetail is 0.348” wide at the bottom so I made the cut 0.347”, the base is 0.060” thick.  The angle is 74 degrees, and the dovetail cutter is the same I used for the front sight. 

As with the latch I first used the dovetail cutter to mill out the center of the cut.  I again milled 0.0025” deep each pass and moved the bit slowly so I wouldn’t damage the bit.  Because the bit was carbide I didn’t worry too much about damaging it.

I kept the dovetail bit at the 0.060” depth and milled the edges of the dovetail.  After milling I cold-blued the exposed metal, then installed the front sight.  It fit nice and tightly in the dovetail.

Dovetailed Front Sight and Loading Lever Latch Installed 

Now both of my Pietta Remington 1858 New Model Army Sheriff’s Models have a dovetailed front sight and loading lever latch.  The front sight is windage adjustable and the loading lever latch can be removed if I need to remove the cylinder base pin.

 

 
   © Copyright 2026 Roy Seifert.